Academic Theories of Why Governments Dislike Cryptocurrency


Image "Take care of mental health 2" created by Kevin Koo using AI art software.


Why do governments dislike crypto? (An elaboration of academic theories)


We asked ChatGPT why it thought governments dislike cryptocurrency, and are trying to remove it from their financial systems. We used several prompts, asking it to link governments' actions to various academic theories. We hope that the following will be a useful and enlightening read. We hope to edit it in due course.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


First Prompt: "Using Granovetter's theory of weak ties, Christensen's disruptive innovation, theory of technology diffusion, institutional theory of organizations, propose a hypothesis on why governments discourage cryptocurrency adoption and attempt to dismantle fiat-crypto on-ramps."


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


One hypothesis is that governments perceive cryptocurrencies as a disruptive innovation that threatens their established institutions and norms of monetary policy and regulation. According to Christensen’s theory of disruptive innovation, a disruptive innovation is a process by which a product or service initially takes root in simple applications at the bottom of a market—typically by being less expensive and more accessible—and then relentlessly moves upmarket, eventually displacing established competitors. Cryptocurrencies can be seen as such an innovation, as they offer an alternative way of storing and transferring value that is decentralized, transparent, secure, and potentially cheaper than traditional fiat currencies. Cryptocurrencies also challenge the authority and legitimacy of central banks and regulators, who have historically controlled the supply and circulation of money.


Another hypothesis is that governments face institutional pressures from various actors and forces that influence their adoption or rejection of cryptocurrencies. According to institutional theory, organizations are subject to institutional systems that consist of regulative, normative, and cognitive elements that shape their behavior and choices. Regulative elements are formal rules and laws that constrain or enable organizational action; normative elements are shared values and expectations that define what is appropriate or desirable; cognitive elements are taken-for-granted beliefs and assumptions that guide organizational interpretation and sensemaking. Governments may resist cryptocurrencies because they violate some of these institutional elements, such as legal frameworks, social norms, or dominant paradigms.


A third hypothesis is that governments have different levels of readiness and willingness to adopt cryptocurrencies depending on their technological capabilities, social structures, and cultural values. According to the theory of technology diffusion, technology diffusion is a process by which an innovation is communicated through certain channels over time among members of a social system. The rate and extent of diffusion depend on various factors, such as the characteristics of the innovation (e.g., relative advantage, compatibility, complexity), the characteristics of the adopters (e.g., innovativeness, risk aversion), the characteristics of the communication channels (e.g., mass media, interpersonal networks), and the characteristics of the social system (e.g., norms, leadership). Governments may differ in their exposure to information about cryptocurrencies; their perception of benefits or risks associated with them; their access to resources or expertise to implement them; their degree of influence or pressure from other actors; their level of openness or resistance to change.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Second Prompt: Using the above explanation which you have given to me, link it to the theory of fitness of survival, evolutionary fitness, and the theory of civilization, to explain the antagonism of governments against cryptocurrency and their attempt to remove it from their financial systems.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


One possible link is that governments view cryptocurrency as a threat to their survival and fitness as dominant institutions in society. According to the theory of fitness of survival, organisms that are better adapted to their environment have a higher chance of surviving and reproducing than those that are less adapted. Similarly, according to evolutionary fitness, organisms that have higher reproductive success relative to other organisms in their population are more fit. Applying these concepts to human societies, we can say that governments that have more power, influence, and resources than other groups or entities are more fit and likely to survive. However, cryptocurrency challenges this fitness by offering an alternative system of value exchange that is decentralized, transparent, secure, and potentially cheaper than traditional fiat currencies. Cryptocurrency also undermines the authority and legitimacy of central banks and regulators who control the supply and circulation of money. Therefore, governments may perceive cryptocurrency as a disruptive innovation that reduces their fitness and threatens their survival.


Another possible link is that governments follow certain norms and values that shape their behavior and choices regarding cryptocurrency. According to the theory of civilization, civilization is a complex human society characterized by cultural and technological development. Civilizations often have certain characteristics such as urbanization, social stratification, state formation, writing systems, agriculture, architecture, infrastructure, taxation, regulation, specialization of labor etc. These characteristics reflect certain norms and values that define what is appropriate or desirable for a civilized society. For example, some civilizations may value stability over change; order over chaos; hierarchy over equality; law over freedom; tradition over innovation etc. These norms and values may influence how governments view cryptocurrency: as a source of instability; disorder; inequality; lawlessness; or novelty. Therefore, governments may resist cryptocurrency because it violates some of these norms and values that they associate with civilization.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Third Prompt: Using the framework of the clash of civilizations, and major sociological theories of society, and social psychology, explain how cryptocurrency represents an active evolution and revolution within a civilization, and how it is a form of resistance, and an expression of unhappiness, against the authoritarian nature of the state.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


One possible explanation is that cryptocurrency reflects a cultural divide between different civilizations that have different values and interests regarding money and power. According to the clash of civilizations theory, global politics is shaped by conflicts between different cultural groups that have distinct identities and worldviews. These groups may be based on religion, ethnicity, language, history, or geography Cryptocurrency can be seen as a product of a certain civilization that values individual freedom, innovation, decentralization, transparency, and security over collective stability, order, centralization, regulation, and trust. This civilization may be associated with Western liberalism, libertarianism, or anarchism.


Cryptocurrency can also be seen as a challenge to other civilizations that have different values and interests regarding money and power. These civilizations may be associated with authoritarianism, statism, or nationalism These civilizations may view cryptocurrency as a threat to their sovereignty, legitimacy, and control over their populations and resources. Therefore, cryptocurrency represents an active evolution and revolution within a civilization that seeks to create an alternative system of value exchange that is independent of state authority and interference. Cryptocurrency also represents a form of resistance and an expression of unhappiness against the authoritarian nature of the state that imposes its will and agenda on its citizens.


Another possible explanation is that cryptocurrency reflects a social change that is driven by technological innovation and diffusion. According to various sociological theories of society, social change is influenced by factors such as technology, culture, economy, politics, environment etc. Technology can have both positive and negative effects on society depending on how it is used and who benefits from it. Technology can also create new opportunities for social interaction and organization that may challenge existing structures and norms. Cryptocurrency can be seen as a technological innovation that has diffused rapidly across different societies due to its advantages over traditional fiat currencies such as lower transaction costs, faster speed, greater accessibility etc.


Cryptocurrency can also be seen as a social change that has created new forms of social interaction and organization such as peer-to-peer networks, online communities, decentralized autonomous organizations etc. These forms may challenge existing structures and norms such as banks, governments, corporations etc. Therefore, cryptocurrency represents an active evolution and revolution within society that seeks to create an alternative system of value exchange that is more efficient, inclusive, and democratic. Cryptocurrency also represents a form of resistance and an expression of unhappiness against the inefficiency, exclusion, and corruption of traditional institutions. These are some possible explanations based on these frameworks.


Thanks for reading


We hope to bring you more educational content in the coming days. Please do not regard anything within this article as legal advice, and please refer to a trained lawyer before making any decision.