Blockchain hacks and getting saved by centralization

Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software.
About that BNB blockchain hack...
Recently the Binance blockchain was exploited to the tune of about $570 million, when some bad actors figured out that the bridge could be used to print about 200 million BNB tokens. The Binance team sprung into action, reached out to validators, and managed to halt the operations of the blockchain. This decisive action managed to help minimize the size of the exploit to only about $100 million. Executives from Binance later said that the hack could have been worse if the validators had not sprung into action.
Currently, Binance has about 44 validators scattered across different time zones. About 27 validators were involved in stopping the hacker from removing all 200 million BNB tokens. In light of this outcome, it could be said that centralization was a boon, not a bane, and actually aided Binance's efforts to stem the damage that resulted from this hack.
Thus, in this short commentary, we make the case that some degree of centralization is necessary for blockchains which are positioned for mass adoption. This state of affairs may be similar to the social contract theory, which early philosophers of jurisprudence put forward.
This isn't the first time, won't be the last time
Other incidents show that hacking of blockchains is an on-going matter. Hackers will continue to target blockchains, and blockchain projects, to exploit poorly coded smart contracts, to attack governance mechanisms, and to phish unsuspecting users.
For example, in March 2022, the Ronin blockchain bridge, linked to P2E game Axie Infinity, was exploited for a whopping $615 million. The U.S. authorities identified North Korean hackers, the Lazarus Group, as the party responsible for the exploit. In the aftermath, Sky Mavis, the creator and operator of the Ronin blockchain, raised about $152 million to finance and continue to build its project.
The leading smart contract blockchain, Ethereum, also suffered a massive hack in 2016, in a project known as The DAO, which led to the project's founders forking the blockchain into the Ethereum (ETH) and Ethereum Classic (ETC) chains. The Ethereum chain (i.e. the forked chain) was rolled back to the point in time where the hack had not taken place; whereas, the Ethereum Classic chain (i.e. the unforked chain) continued without any rollbacks, where the losses were recognised.
In the first case, the community did not decide to roll back the chain, even though, as a commercial entity, Sky Mavis would have been in a position to do so. In the second case, the community was split over whether to roll back or not, so the Ethereum team decided to let its tokenholders have their cake and eat it as well, by hard forking it and giving them two sets of tokens instead of one.
Which approach is the right approach? This is a valid question because the entire ethos of web3 and blockchains is premised on the promise of the blockchain, which is, among other things, immutable. That means it is not supposed to be modifiable, it is supposed to be unchangeable. Which makes the idea of a roll back despicable to many.

Image created by Kevin Koo with the assistance of AI software.
What is the social contract? Why does it matter for blockchains?
The social contract is, in simple language, the idea that people are all born free, but if they want to live together, each of them needs to submit to a central authority, thus, giving up part of their freedom. This will give authority and power to the central authority, while giving these people the assurance of a peaceful existence.
Even though people wish to live their lives in freedom, yet, they would be unprotected in their original state. But in seeking protection, people must create a state, which governs their behaviour through its laws, and with that, the creation of organs of the state, such as police and army, which are enforcers of the law.
Blockchains are in a state of continuous evolution. Code is often being updated with proposals coming from one of the community members. Naturally, with many moving parts, things break and vulnerabilities may arise. An attacker may find a vulnerability to exploit before it is patched. Thus, the existence of a central authority which can stop all operations on the blockchain, is important.
With blockchains, the promise given is that it is append-only, therefore, all transactions are final, and irreversible. But this means that even maliciously executed transactions, such as a transfer of a large sum of crypto, at gunpoint, could also be seen as final and irreversible. Whereas, it would be clear in such circumstances that the transferor had never intended, nor consented, to the transfer. Is such a state of affairs fair, or is it unjust?
If the governance team of a blockchain has the discretion and the authority to push for a rollback of a set of transactions, would it be fair for the community? Would allowing the community to suffer a loss, in the name of decentralization and immutability, be fair? Or would allowing a roll back set a precedent which informs the community that a blockchain is immutable only until it is not convenient to be immutable, and can be rolled back even to its genesis block if the governance team so decides?
This brings us to the next part of our discussion. In the context of financial technologies, regulators would tend to approve what is called a circuit breaker technology. Let's dive into it...

Art created by Kevin Koo.
What is a circuit breaker?
A circuit breaker is a mechanism implemented in a financial market place, which allows it to halt all operations. A circuit breaker is a must-have feature for any traditional finance marketplace, for the purpose of halting all activity. One reason could be the suspected manipulation of price action, which could be harmful to retail investors if unchecked.
A circuit breaker mechanism is often desirable in the view of the regulators. It means that they can stop damage before it becomes a contagion beyond their control.
Binance, as the largest crypto exchange in the world, has built up its SAFU fund to a size of $1 billion. Its goal? To compensate users in case of a hack. In other words, Binance self-insures its users with its own funds, to the sum of $1 billion in aggregate, without needing users to pay for this insurance. (They make enough in trading fees to set up the fund.)
Yet, looking at the size of the BNB chain bridge exploit, which was $570 million in total, it was a good thing for Binance, and BNB token holders in general, that more than 80% of the funds (i.e. the 200 million BNB tokens) were frozen before they could be withdrawn by the hackers. In this matter, it is true that BNB holders would not have suffered a loss of their holdings, since the 200 million BNB were printed (freshlyprinted, mind you), but they would have suffered a loss in value as the hackers liquidated their holdings.
Thus, having the ability to halt such nefarious activity is a good thing for BNB and the crypto world at large, not least because Binance is an important player, and having a system that is vulnerable to exploits is like having a leaky bucket that nobody will want to use in the long term, which means that the BNB token will drop in value if exploits continue.
In that light, perhaps Solana's ability to switch its network on and off could be marketed as a feature rather than a bug. But that's a discussion for another day. What is clear is that it is not easy to shut off a blockchain entirely unless there is good coordination among the validators of the blockchain. For example, it would be nearly impossible to shut down the Bitcoin blockchain because of the large number of nodes on the network. As long as even a fraction of the present number continue to run nodes, the blockchain will continue to run.
In the end, perhaps centralization should be seen as a good thing, because the creators of a blockchain, who have a vested interest in protecting the blockchain against attacks, have one more tool to use against nefarious bad actors. And it is one more tool that can safeguard the funds of users.
Thanks for reading.

