EULA for Metaverse Games

Art created with AI software by Kevin Koo.
What is a EULA
The End User License Agreement (EULA) is a legally binding contract between the software provider and the end-user, defining the terms of the license for end-users who use the software. In today's discussion, the software is none other than metaverse games, which, if you did not realize yet, is a form of software. EULA establish what users (or players) can and cannot do. At the same time, it also defines the intellectual property rights of the software providers.
In such cases, EULA should be made available on the software website, where it can be easily accessed by the end users. Ideally, the end users should confirm that they agree to the EULA before their user accounts are created. This ensures that they, as end-users, cannot circumvent the terms nor plead ignorance.
In some cases, the terms in the EULA have been the grounds that software publishers rely upon to take, or at least threaten to take, against end users who use the software in ways that breach the EULA. For example, in 2022, the NFT project, NFT Worlds, launched, using Minecraft as its underlying technology. Minecraft is a popular 3D environment, which has many users. Minecraft's owners, Mojang, objected to the use of the software for NFTs and threatened legal action. In response, the NFT Worlds project owner declared that they would create their own game.
Interestingly, there has been some discussion about the legal implications of microtransactions, which are put in place by publishers, to milk their players for in-game credits of in-game benefits, and whether it breaches the EULA. However, in today's article, we are here to discuss why software publishers should include EULA for their software, and how it could benefit them, and some of the important clauses in the EULA.
But before that...
EULA as a shield
The EULA can be a shield for software publishers, by prohibiting certain types of users based on their age, their geographical locations, their country's laws (jurisdictions), their personal personal faith, and/or their personal affiliations.
For example, a metaverse project that I worked with to draft up their EULA specifically required that only users above the age of 18 can use the metaverse; and that no sort of pornography or mature content could be placed within the metaverse. Yet, another metaverse project wanted to work with mature content producers, and specifically required that only users from jurisdictions which permitted mature content, would be allowed to use the software.
To each his own, but by having certain restrictive clauses in the EULA, the software publishers of the metaverse project can revoke a user's rights, suspend the account, or at the very least, issue a warning to the said user. When a project grows into thousands of active daily users, it will be difficult to establish which players are flouting the rules, and MMORPG companies rely on user complaints to catch these bad actors, or on administrative staff who make it their business to pry into what users are doing.
Additional restrictive clauses which some EULA stipulate are that anything which is deemed an offence or illegal under the law, is prohibited; that the user's rights to class action is waived by using the software; that the user agrees to submit to certain dispute resolution methods; and so on and so forth. Of the whole lot, it seems that a waiver to class action would be a smart move; one that reduces the risk of rent seeking users who deliberately find fault with the software, and hope to walk away with a settlement. By waiving the right to a class action, the user who has a dispute, is forced to take up the matter with the software publisher on a personal basis.
Another provision that a EULA can include is a limitation of damages that a user can claim against the software publisher; based on a certain formula, such as the total amount paid by the said user during the immediate past 12 months to the software publisher.
EULA that incorporates other EULA
To be honest, this was the real reason that piqued our interest in this topic. One of the metaverse projects that I worked with incorporated Unreal Engine technologies into its metaverse; and Unreal Engine had a EULA which required its users to bundle certain notices with their own product's EULA.
Thus, for example, if a project makes a certain amount of money, it would need to start paying royalties to Epic Games, the owner of Unreal Engine; but not if the project was a nonprofit, or if it did not hit the threshold. Where our client created its own NFT-based metaverse, which each plot could then be turned into its own metaverse, we were minded to give notice to the NFT holders that they could potentially be under obligation to pay a royalty to Epic Games, if their revenue hit $1 million.
For a software publisher, if your product or service incorporates software libraries, certain technologies, or are based on other software, you have to respect the EULA terms set by that software publisher, failing which, you may be banned by the software publisher from using the software -- similar to how the NFT Worlds project received a warning from Mojang for running afoul of the Minecraft EULA.
Common terms in a EULA
In a EULA for a metaverse project, the following terms may be present:
Open Source. If a software is licensed as open source, it may also specify an open source license; otherwise, if a software uses open source code, it may state that fact, but also the fact that the software itself is licensed similarly (if it was required by the open source code).
Intellectual Property Rights. Similar to the open source license, a clause about intellectual property rights is usually present to protect the software against people that wish to reverse engineer the code, copy the code, or even extract game assets to be used elsewhere.
Age and geographical restrictions. As stated above, a software publisher may wish to exclude certain users from its platform.
Prohibited uses.. As stated above, there may be a need to prohibit certain types of activity, for example, pornography or anything related to drugs and weapons, and activities of a criminal nature.
Dispute Jurisdiction. A dispute jurisdiction clause simply states how a problem arising from the platform is to be resolved; and in many cases, the software publisher would specify arbitration. However, online arbitration is faster, if it is available.
Privacy. A software publisher may collect data and/or pass on the user's data to a third party for processing.
Chargeable Items. If there are any chargeable items which are payable by the user, the EULA is a good place to mention it.
Basis of Access. If the metaverse plot can only be accessed by a certain means, e.g. by holding a certain NFT, which requires a wallet to be connected to the website, then it should be stated.
Potential Fees or Royalties Payable. In the case of the metaverse project that I assisted last year, we issued a notice to the project's users that if their projects, which incorporated Epic Games' technology, made more than a certain amount, they would be liable to pay royalties to Epic Games.
Disclaimers. Disclaimers are where the software publisher states explicitly the risks in using the software; in the case of a metaverse project, it may be prudent to disclaim that data will be stored persistently, and that the users are required to back up their own data; also, it may be prudent to disclaim that the software would be suitable for any implied kind of purpose, because you never know what the user has in mind, which may be beyond the capabilities of the software.
Waivers. Waivers are where you give notice to a user that the user would have to forgo certain rights if they decide to use the software. In the case of a metaverse project, a waiver on class action would be a start; but also require the user to waive its rights to any compulsory litigation outside of the stipulated dispute resolution forum (place).
Wallet Security. In crypto, and especially in NFTs and metaverses, there are times when the user has to connect his wallet to a website. There is a chance that the user would log into a fake website, connect his wallet, and lose hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of tokens and NFTs. And thus it seems appropriate to include a clause in the EULA that requires the user to be solely responsible for ensuring that the website is the genuine website before connecting.
Sample EULA
We will attempt to put up a generic EULA for metaverse projects to adopt.
This is all for now. Thanks for reading.

