Influencers and their liability

Recently, a new NFT project called Art Gobblers became popular. A number of influencers received their NFTs for free, which they sold at the peak of the Art Gobblers pump, when it hit about 20 eth. A few days after the Art Gobblers' launch, the project now has a floor price of about 7 eth.
Many influencers did not reveal that they received their NFTs for free. As a result, they gave the impression that they were like other NFT collectors, who were asked to mint or buy the NFTs on the secondary markets. The truth was that they were not the same.
So the question may be, whether these influencers are responsible for losses suffered by their followers? Can their followers who followed their "alpha", hold them accountable, even if these influencers told their followers, "This is not financial advice, please DYOR". (DYOR means "do your own research".)
Legal aspects of influencer liability
So, can influencers who cause losses to their followers be held accountable? There may be several aspects of this question.
One aspect, may be that these "influencers" are liable to their followers if they pumped the project without disclosing the fact that they were paid. The fact that they were being rewarded in some form or other, should have been disclosed, and when it wasn't disclosed, they were not being honest with their followers. In this perspective, we would say that the followers would not have followed the influencer, if they knew that the influencers were being rewarded.
But influencers can and will be rewarded from time to time. What else should be present in order for an influencer to be held accountable?
Another aspect, is if the influencer had promised his or her followers that they would benefit from getting into a project. It would set up their followers with an expectation of profiting from the project; and that would make it closer to the definition of an "investment project" under the Howey Test, which is the test commonly used by the US SEC to determine whether an "investment contract" exists.
What are some examples of promises of profit? These may include:
- Promise of the project becoming a quick flip;
- Promise that the project would be entry to future airdrops, whether in the form of a token or an affiliated NFT;
- Promise that the project would be giving "staking" utility.
But not every influencer is going to come and pump it like that. Some instead come with a thread, and some with a backstory about the project. In the case of the Art Gobblers, the backstory was that the project was created by the "Rick and Morty" animated series creators. Which is OK by itself, but with the presence of influencers, the FOMO became quite thick. Hence the floor price going up to 20 eth.
In any case, the Art Gobblers NFT project is not an ordinary one; it has its mechanics where NFT tokens are used to create certain dynamics. (This seems to be a trend among NFT projects, like WZRDS in which NFT holders could "burn" other NFTs which sold below a certain price; or the Primates, which could be "toxified"; or others..)
Perhaps it was just a case of collector exuberance, and it could be explained like that. But securities regulators around the world also have a thing for "market manipulation", where prices are skewed and profits are taken, by the efforts of certain individuals which distort the actual market scenario. And that may be worth exploring in terms of influencer marketing for NFT projects; and influencer liability.
What are some cases of influencers being prosecuted in the past?
In the world of NFTs, there have not been any notable cases of influencers being prosecuted for pumping a project.
However, in the world of tokens, there have been a number of cases, which bear repeating here:
- Kim Kardashian was fined by the US SEC for promoting EthereumMax. The problem was not that she didn't disclose that she was being compensated; it was that she didn't disclose how much compensation she was receiving. So, in the end, she received $250,000 in compensation, but was fined $1.6 million.
- In 2018, the US SEC fined DJ Khaled $152,725, for failing to disclose that he had been paid $50,000 by Centra Tech to promote its ICO. Floyd Mayweather Jr, who failed to disclose that he was paid $100,000 by Centra Tech, and $200,000 to promote another two ICOs, was fined $614,775. (The amount of the fine is always more than the amount of compensation received.)
There are probably more enforcement action history which we could list, but in the interest of keeping this article brief, suffice to say that failing to disclose that you're being compensated is one of the things that the US SEC is looking out for. Bear in mind the other aspects that were discussed in this article.
For all influencers, who are thinking of cashing in on your followers, you may wish to reach out to the Crypto Legal Info team and have a word with us before taking the leap.
Thanks for reading.

