Launching a Token In A Compliant Way


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software.

Introduction - launching tokens in the past.

In 2017, the most popular use case of the Ethereum blockchain was to create ERC20 tokens.  Tokens were sold in ICOs – initial coin offerings. Some of those ICOs were huge. For example, the EOS ICO raised USD4 billion in crypto; Tezos ICO raised USD232 million; and so on. Many of those tokens were sold as ERC20 tokens, placeholders for tokens on a future layer 1 blockchain that would compete with Ethereum. When the new blockchains launched, the ERC20 tokens (on Ethereum) would be swapped for the native tokens of the new blockchain.

 

The most popular instrument at that time was the SAFT agreement, i.e. the Simple Agreement for Future Tokens.  The SAFT was adapted from Y Combinator’s SAFE agreement, the Simple Agreement for Future Equity.  Another popular instrument was the Private Placement Memorandum (PPM), which was available for accredited, sophisticated or qualified investors. (Depending on your jurisdiction.)

 

The SAFT was a fairly popular instrument, but there were others like it, such as the Private Placement Memorandum. Click the blue button to view the SAFT Project website, where you can download the forms for the SAFT. 


THE SAFT PROJECT WEBSITE

Why launch your token in a compliant way?

The simple answer to that question is that regulation continues to evolve.  Beginning in 2018, the US SEC began enforcement actions against people that they believed sold unlicensed securities. That set off some changes in the industry. 


Exchanges began to offer token launchpads, essentially underwriting and selling the tokens on their platform. This method was called the IEO (initial exchange offering), and had the added advantage of ensuring that the tokens would be listed on the exchange after the token sale was over. It also meant that the sale was carried out by the launchpad platform owner, and not the token project owners themselves.

 

But the regulations did not relent, and people started talking about doing compliant sales of securities tokens. This was called an STO (securities token offering), and would be restricted to qualified, sophisticated or accredited investors.  STOs would have an advantage as being recognised under law as outright securities.


The landscape continued to evolve and there is now a bifurcation.


On the one hand, there are anonymous token launch mechanisms, airdrops, and liquidity pools on DEXes. These options have gained prominence as some token issuers decide to issue tokens anonymously. Some of them may be NFT projects, trying to create an economy for their token holders. One example was the $APE token, which was airdropped to BAYC NFT token holders.


On the other hand, many token launches are non-anonymous, which is important if you want the project to grow and scale. If you want to issue a token using your company, with the idea that the tokens be used within the company, this might seem like an attractive option. It would also give credence to the claim that your token is a "utility token", which would be used in the platform that your company is planning to launch. 


However, there is a drawback: if you're non-anonymous, it means that you can be identified, and action taken against you if there is a complaint of a scam etc.


So to come back to the question, why a token sale must be compliant, let us enumerate the reasons. First, failure to comply with regulations could result in legal consequences for the project and the individuals involved, including fines and other penalties. Second, being compliant helps to build trust and credibility with potential investors, as it shows that the project is transparent and adhering to the rules set by the governing authority. This can make it more likely for the token sale to be successful, as investors will be more willing to participate in a sale that is perceived as being trustworthy and well-managed. Fourth, compliance with regulations can help to protect investors from fraud and other potential risks associated with investing in tokens. By ensuring that the token sale is compliant, the project team can help to create a safer and more secure investment environment.


If you are planning to launch a token, these are good reasons to consider launching it in a compliant way.


The evolution of the SAFT

The SAFT stands for "Simple Agreement for Future Tokens" and it was launched around 2017-2018. When it was first created, the SAFT was aimed at allowing projects to sell their tokens in a way that complied with securities regulations.


It relied on a two step process, which meant that the tokens were delivered at a later date, similar to a pre-order.  The tokens themselves were not delivered until the network launched, or went operational. At that point of time, the tokens would become usable in the network, and take on the status of "utility token".  This marked a break from pre-2017 token sales in which tokens were sold outright to token buyers. 


However, over time, the SAFT became the most popular instrument for token sales, and the SEC began to look at prosecuting token issuers who abused the SAFT.  


The US SEC managed to cast doubt on the utility of the SAFT in two court cases: Its case against Telegram, and its case against KIK Interactive Inc.  Both of these cases happened in 2020.


In the case of Telegram, the US SEC obtained a consent order for Telegram (Telegram Group Inc. and its wholly owned subsidiary, TON Issuer Inc.) to return $1.2 billion to its investors, while also paying a fine of $18 million to the SEC as a penalty. The SEC had argued in its complaint that the "Gram token", which Telegram sold, was unregistered under US securities laws, and paved the way for greater distribution to the general public in the US. 


In the case of KIK Interactive Inc., the US SEC again obtained a consent order that the sales of the "Kin tokens" were securities investment contracts, and that KIK would pay a fine of $5 million to the SEC as a penalty. 


In both cases, the US courts considered the fact that the tokens would eventually be resold to the US public, thus making it an illegal, unregistered sale of securities. The uncensorable nature of blockchains means that tokens can be sold across the globe once they have been transferred into the hands of a purchaser. 


However, not all registered token sales are equal.

For example, the Celsius token, CEL was sold in a compliant way. It was registered with the US SEC. However, as you probably know by now, Celsius suffered a terrible meltdown in the aftermath of the Terra Luna downfall, alongside others like 3 Arrows Capital (3AC), Voyager, and most recently FTX. What this means is that, even if the sale of the token itself is compliant, the management of the company may not be. Many companies operate as a "black box", which auditors are unable to check or audit properly for a want of expertise. Witness, for example, the revelation that FTX had a "backdoor access" which allowed SBF to withdraw funds and to alter accounts, without being detected.


(This article is still being researched. Please come back soon.)


Token sale in the US - Options to consider

A token sale is considered compliant with regulations if it follows the rules and guidelines set by the governing authority in the jurisdiction where the sale is taking place. You also need to consider the profile of your token buyers. This may differ from country to country, but in the US, a compliant token sale can be carried out under Regulation A, D or S.


At the same time, there has been historical precedence (pre-2020) for projects to sell pure utility tokens with a letter of non-objection, or " from the US SEC. Examples include the TKJ (Turn Key Jets) token and the Q2 (Pocketful of Quarters) token.  (For the lawyers reading this, here is PoQ's lawyers writing to the SEC). 


Regulation A and Regulation D are two different sets of rules that govern certain types of securities offerings in the United States.


Regulation A is a set of rules that allows companies to offer and sell securities to the general public, including through crowdfunding platforms. This type of offering is sometimes called a "mini-IPO" because it is similar to an initial public offering (IPO), but with lower requirements for the amount of information that needs to be disclosed. Regulation A offerings are subject to certain limits on the amount of money that can be raised and the type of investors who can participate.


Regulation D, on the other hand, is a set of rules that allows companies to offer and sell securities without registering the offering with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). This type of offering is typically reserved for private placements, where the securities are sold to a limited number of accredited investors. Regulation D offerings are not subject to the same disclosure requirements as public offerings, but they are subject to limits on the number of investors who can participate and the way the securities can be advertised.


In summary, the main difference between Regulation A and Regulation D is the type of offering they govern and the requirements for disclosure and investor participation. Regulation A governs offerings to the general public, while Regulation D governs private placements to accredited investors.


In my view, if you're a small US-based startup and you're looking to do things in a compliant way, Regulation D is your best bet -- offering unregistered securities through private placements.  As this SEC Investor Bulletin says, within Regulation D, there are rule 506 and 504 which spell out how these private placements can be carried out. (The Final Rule can be read here.)


Rule 506(b) allows you (as token issuer) to raise an unlimited amount of money, from an unlimited number of accredited investors, but no more than 35 non-accredited investors.


An accredited investor is described as:

- a person who earned more than $200,000 in each of the past 2 years, and expects to earn the same for the current year; OR

- a person has a net worth of more than $1 million, either alone or with a spouse, or spousal equivalent (exclusing the value of his residence, and loans secured by the residence); OR

- a broker or other financial professional, in good standing, with certain qualifications, including Series 7, 65 or 82 license.


"Non-accredited investors" must be financially sophisticated, meaning they have sufficient knowledge and experience in financial and business matters to evaluate the investment. 


Under rule 506(b), you (as a token issuer) cannot generally solicit for investors.


Under rule 506(c), however, you could solicit or advertise for potential investors. That means that you (as token issuer) could, under rule 506(c), run an offering and advertise it on the newspaper, or the Internet, or even TV. But rule 506(c) allows you to sell to accredited investors only, so if you have a potential investor, you must take steps to confirm his accredited investor status.


Then, there's Rule 504. Under Rule 504, a token issuer can raise up to $10 million within a 12 month period from any type of investor, without limit to the number of investors. That means, if you want to run a token offering to offer tokens to the widest number possible, Rule 504 is probably it. 


And that brings us to Regulation S. A token sale under Regulation S allows you to raise funds from persons outside the United States. If you are running a website, you may have to geo-fence it. This is to ensure compliance with the regulations which require that the token sale take place outside the US. 


Within Regulation S, there are also several Rules, which dictate what can and cannot be done. Rule 903, 904 and 905 are relevant here. 


With Rule 903, there are three Categories. For all three Categories 1, 2, and 3, the sale (a) must occur offshore; and (b) there must not be any directed selling efforts in the United States.


Additionally, with Category 1, the issuer (a) must believe there is no substantial US market interest in the offering; and (b) the sale is an overseas directed offering. The securities must be (c) backed by the full faith of a foreign government, or, alternatively, (d) sold to the employees of the issuer under an employment benefits plan.


With Category 2, the securities being offered (which do not qualify as Category 1 securities), must be (a) restricted in their offering; (b) the offer for sale, if made within a 40 days distribution compliance period, cannot be made to a US citizen or someone acting for his benefit; (c) each distributor selling the securities to another distributor, or dealer, or anyone receiving a professional commission or fee, must prior to the expiry of the 40 day distribution compliance period, send a notice saying, the purchaser is subject to the same restrictions on offers and sales, as applies to a distributor. 


With Category 3, the securities being offered (which do not qualify as Category 1 or Category 2 securities), must be (a) restricted in their offering; (b) if debt securities, cannot be offered to a US based person within the 40 day distribution compliance period, and cannot be exchanged for definitive securities within the 40 day distribution compliance period; and the securities are owned by a non-US person; or a US person who was not required to register under the Act; (c) if equity securities, cannot be offered to a US based person within the 1 year distribution compliance period; and such purchaser must agree to resell the securities following Regulation S; securities must have a notice saying that transfers need to follow Regulation S.


Under Rule 904, an offer or sale of securities is deemed to have occurred outside the US if the offer or sale was made in an offshore transaction; and there were no directed selling efforts in the USA.


(Note: As the writer of this article, I must disclaim that even though I am a lawyer, I am not qualified to practise in the US. Therefore, please check with a US lawyer before launching your token sale.) 


Token sale in Malaysia

Malaysia's compliant token sale procedure is called the "IEO", or Initial Exchange Offering. The party selling the tokens is called the "IEO issuer". Each IEO issuer needs to work with an "IEO Operator", which has been authorized by the Securities Commission of Malaysia.


The requirements for the IEO issuer (i.e., the token project owner) are that the company has a paid up capital of RM500,000.00 (Ringgit), and has two directors who reside in Malaysia. Prior to the token sale, board members and senior management must own at least 50% of the company. Post-token sale, however, the board members and senior management can only transfer up to half of their share holdings, until the project is completed.


The requirements for the IEO Operator are that the company has a paid up capital of RM5 million (ringgit), and have at least one independent director. There must be at least one responsible person i.e. the CEO or person responsible for the IEO Operator's operations.


In both cases, the IEO issuer and the IEO Operator need to have directors that meet the "fit and proper" criteria.


In the Malaysian framework, the IEO Operator vets through the white paper of the IEO issuer. An IEO issuer who finds support from the IEO Operator can go on to sell a maximum of RM100 million worth of tokens.


Retail investors can invest up to RM2,000 per offering, with a maximum of RM20,000 per year. Angel investors (which earn not less than RM180,000 per annum), they may invest up to RM500,000 per year. Sophisticated investors have no maximum on their investments.


As an alternative to a token sale under the purview of the Securities Commission (i.e. the federal regulator), you may wish to consider a token sale under the credit token license. We've already written an article about launching a stablecoin from Labuan -- the same credit token guidelines apply.


What token sale instrument should you use?

We come back to the instrument that we discussed, when we started this article -- the SAFT. In fact, there is nothing wrong with this instrument today, but you would need to customize the "event" that triggers the delivery of the tokens. In the old versions, you would have a "Network Event", i.e. when the new layer-1 blockchain networks launch, thereby justifying the release of the tokens to investors. But not every token would be sold for the creation of new layer-1 blockchains. Some may be sold as a DeFi token, some may be sold as a GameFi token, and others still may be sold as a stablecoin. So some tweaking of the SAFT would be required.


Since the platform for the tokens are not yet operational, it is better to style them as "future tokens", The tokens would have utility once the network is launched; therefore satisfying the label of "utility token". However, there are also tokens which qualify as securities, and in such case, it is better to check with your local regulator before launching the securities tokens.


Thanks for reading!