Mass Looting


The Nomad Bridge Mass-Looting

This week, the Nomad Bridge was hacked due to an error in the coding, which auto-approved every transaction. Once the flaw in the system became known to the public, many decided to join what one Twitter user called the "first mass-looting" in the history of crypto. The total amount of loss from the hack was estimated to be about USD 200 million.


However, in the aftermath of the incident, it turned out that a number of those who withdrew funds from the Nomad Bridge were actually doing so benevolently. They withdrew the funds to their own wallets, with the intention of returning the funds to Nomad Bridge. The operators of the Nomad Bridge have called them "white hat hackers", and subsequently issued a notice that they would encourage "white hat hackers" to return 90% of whatever funds they had withdrawn, and keep 10% as a "bug bounty".


In light of this incident, one legal aspect of the matter would be, whether a person who decides to return the funds only after being identified, can afford the defence of "benevolent looting" ? Would this sort of "amnesty" in which a hacker, who participated in the mass-looting, be afforded to the individuals who choose to keep the funds for the moment? 


In the matter of mass-looting, the claim of being a "white hat hacker" may indeed be used as part of a defence of necessity in a court of law, In other words, a "white hat hacker" may claim that it is the lesser of two evils that they chose: The choice between allowing the entirety of the funds to be looted (which is bad), or, to partake in the looting with the goal of saving the returning a portion of the funds to the Nomad Bridge operators eventually (which is acceptable).


However, because the Nomad Bridge team is now pleading with the public to return the stolen funds, it is in the best interest of these "white hat hackers" to respond to their "amnesty" as soon as possible, before they are identified by forensic tools such as Chainalysis.


It is possible that the Nomad Bridge, which is run by a company, may eventually be wound up due to insolvency. However, this does not negate the criminal liability of any hacker who wishes to hide behind the claim of being a "white hat hacker". 


Solana Wallet Slope Hacked

Another significant piece of news this week was the incident of about 8,000 Solana wallets being drained seemingly overnight. Investigations revealed that the vulnerability exploited by the attacker was the Slope wallet, which stored the private keys of wallets that it had created, on its server in plain text. The total loss to users 


This incident was similar to another vulnerability discovered in the NEAR Protocol wallet, sometime in June 2022, which was fixed on the same day of its discovery. Slope wallet is a web-based Solana wallet, similar to the NEAR Protocol wallet which is also web-based. Web-based wallets exist on other blockchain platforms as well, such as the Algorand wallet. Web-based wallets are subject to various vulnerabilities, which include email phishing, clone sites, malware, fake browser extensions, etc. 


Unlike the Nomad Bridge mass-looting, the Solana-based Slope wallet losses are caused by a single bad actor, or a single group of bad actors. Like the Nomad Bridge incident, however, it has caused losses to users who decided to put their trust in the service provided by the company. Would the company be responsible for the losses, and refund the users who have been affected by the hack?