Privacy and the Celsius Court Papers


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software


Celsius court filing = data privacy breach

Celsius Network, the centralized finance company that is going through a bankruptcy case in the US courts, is in fresh trouble. A document which runs more than 14,000 pages, has been filed as part of bankruptcy proceedings, to show the transactions that really took place. All well and good, but this court document also exposes the names of every depositor / user of the platform, including the large whales who are now exposed and at risk.


A whale is the term used to describe someone with a lot of bitcoin; and in the case of Celsius, it attracted many whales who wished to deposit their cryptocurrencies with Celsius to earn interest. Even though most Celsius users may have had only a small amount of tokens, such as ETH, the presence of customers with substantial crypto holdings, whose identity has been inadvertantly "doxxed" (exposed), represents significant risk to these individuals. These customers, whose transactions histories have been exposed, have reason to fear. Past events show that kidnappings and robberies have taken place in the past, thus putting crypto holders in danger for their personal safety.


What is the Celsius customer court document about?

The Celsius court document was a filing that contains many, if not all (we haven't seen the document ourselves), of the Celsius customer names, and their transaction histories. It also shows how some of their executives have transacted on the platform. In a bankruptcy case, especially when wrongful handling of company funds is alleged, it is commonplace for documents to be produced for the court to make a finding. However, as stated earlier in this article, the unredacted / uncensored publication of users' personal details and the history of their private transactions, is tantamount to doxxing (wilful exposure) that can harm these users.


How did Celsius customer names get into the document?

It is likely that these customer' details were voluntarily provided to Celsius as part of the KYC / AML regulatory compliance procedures. In other words, when a customer becomes a user of Celsius platform, their account would be limited in functionality until they comply with KYC requirements. KYC commonly involves the provision of a government-issued document, such as a driving license or a passport, to the platform's operators, who can then verify the identify of the user. 


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software


What is Celsius?

Celsius is a cryptocurrency lender, or sometimes known as a crypto lender. It deals with depositors who place their BTC or other crypto into its custody; and promises them a return on their deposit. At the same time, they lend money, or crypto, to users who agree to pay it a fee. Unfortunately, Celsius is now undergoing bankruptcy proceedings, and users have not been able to effect any withdrawal. Much of its funds is being held by a trustee. During its heyday, its CEO Alex Mashinsky portrayed Celsius as a safe, regulated financial services provider, where users funds would be safe. This has turned out to be untrue, and it is at risk of going bankrupt, and its users may be unable to withdraw their funds before the inevitable happens.


2022 has been an eventful year for the crypto industry, with a litany of bad news, starting from the explosive unwinding of the UST which directly caused the unbelievable insolvency of Three Arrows Capital. The chapter 11 bankruptcy which Celsius filed for protection from creditors is only another episode is a series of events which is shaking up the crypto industry.


But why didn't Celsius attempt to redact information? 

Celsius did try to redact information. It made an application to the court to request that the information exposed in the court document be limited because (a) the names and details of its customers represent a valuable asset, which could be devalued after being published; (b) its customers could become the targets of crimes, such as phishing and robberies; and (c) it could expose Celsius to regulatory action from regulators in various jurisdictions, because its customers come from jurisdictions around the world.


However, its submissions were opposed by the U.S. Trustee, which argued that: (a) bankruptcy proceedings should be open; (b) the information sought to be redacted is not commercial nor private information; (c) Celsius' own policies allow its customers data to be shared with third parties, and therefore its customer information is not really confidential and private; (d) Celsius was not seeking to redact names and identifying data for all users, but only certain users, thus the data was not really confidential and private; (e) US bankruptcy law prevails over foreign laws, and US bankruptcy law requires filings to be public; (f) the threat of violence against doxed customers is only anecdotal evidence. 


Update on the document 

The document, which was originally uploaded to Archive.org by Gizmodo, is no longer available. Numerous articles such as this one from Decrypt referenced the document before it was taken offline. The Defiant noted that the document did not include the users' home addresses, which is a small consolation given that in this day and age of social media, it is possible to discover the identities of persons through triangulation of details.


Perhaps some saving grace out of this episode is that prominent YouTuber and internet sleuth CoffeeZilla used the document to identify USD2.7 million that Krissy Mashinsky (wife of former CEO), withdrew right before former CEO Alex Mashinsky announced that withdrawals would be frozen.