Update: SCRT Labs accuses Secret Foundation of mishandling funds


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software.


Note: This news update has been prepared with the assistance of AI software by the BCTA team. Your feedback is welcome. 


Summary

The Secret Foundation has been accused of mishandling funds and lacking transparency. Founder and CEO Tor Bair has rejected these accusations and proposed a reform plan. Guy Zyskind, the founder and CEO of SCRT Labs, has released a statement with a four-point “initial blueprint” for a different vision for transforming the foundation.


Guy Zyskind, founder and CEO of Secret Labs, raised a number of questions around the past operations of the Secret Foundation and its founder Tor Bair. These included a lack of transparency from the foundation, an alleged mishandling of an OTC sale that incurred a loss of about $250,000 and a potential open loan to collapsed trading firm Alameda. Bair responded to the claims, confirming that he sold $2.6 million of secret tokens in 2021, and suggested that the foundation should be restructured or establish a global board. He also acknowledged the mishandled OTC sale, which he had previously disclosed on the governance forum.


SmartStake, a major validator in the Cosmos ecosystem, has announced that it will shut down its nodes following revelations around the Secret Foundation’s founder, Tor Bair, personally taking profits. NotionalDAO, another Cosmos validator, has echoed SmartStake’s statement. Guy Zyskind, the founder of Secret Labs, posted a statement in which the allegations were made public. Bair also announced the same governance forum stating that the withdrawals were simply part of his vested tokens. A debate continued to wage within the comments, and on Twitter, as to whether the community believes there has been malpractice or whether people are more concerned that Bair appeared to have sold the top at over $7.


Issues

Lack of transparency, mishandling of funds, personal intimidation.


Lack of transparency from the foundation, alleged mishandling of an OTC sale, potential open loan to collapsed trading firm Alameda, Bair's token sales.


Allegations of malpractice by Tor Bair, founder of the Secret Foundation, taking profits without disclosure to the community, and selling tokens at the top of the market.


Chronology

Early troubles surfaced in 2020 when it was revealed that the Secret Foundation was established as a for-profit corporation. In August 2022, the community passed a proposal aimed at enhancing transparency into the foundation’s finances. In December 2022, the conflict came to a head when both Zyskind and Bair released statements on the community forum.


Zyskind raised the allegations in a post on the Secret Network governance forum. Bair responded to the claims in the same forum, confirming that he sold $2.6 million of secret tokens in 2021. He had previously disclosed the mishandled OTC sale on the governance forum in December.


Allegations were made public on Jan. 27, 2023. Bair began earning a salary in 2021 and vesting “a portion of my tokens” by December. Bair made an “OTC sale of SCRT tokens” in Q4 2021.


Regulatory Aspects

According to Bair, Secret Foundation Inc. is a for-profit business registered in Illinois, so it would not be unlawful for Bair to receive a dividend. Doing so would have required notice to shareholders, however, which does not appear to have been issued. It would have also needed to be reported in the company’s tax filings, which Bair claims SCRT Labs reviewed.


Actionable Advice

Zyskind has proposed a four-point “initial blueprint” for a different vision for transforming the foundation. These include returning all funds currently held by Secret Foundation to the community in order to set up a new Secret Foundation with new leadership; registering the new organization as a non-profit; setting up a long-term funding program, and sending budgeting requests to the Secret blockchain; and establishing a board of directors.


Bair suggested that the foundation should be restructured or establish a global board, and that there should be standards set for compensation and transparency going forward.


Related Matters

  1. The Secret Network community is not happy with what they’ve learned about the Secret Foundation.
  2. SmartStake and NotionalDAO shutting down their nodes in response to the allegations.


References

  1. Secret Foundation Faces Calls for More Transparency, Return of Funds, published 30.1.2023 by Decrypt
  2. Secret Labs and Secret Foundation battle it out openly, published 29.1.2023 by The Block
  3.  Validators shut down as Secret Network struggles with leadership, published 30.1.2023 by Cryptoslate