Web 3 and the Service of Court Documents

Art by Kevin Koo with the help of AI.
Serving Court Documents - Introduction
Service of documents is an essential part of court proceedings. Court proceedings operate on procedural fairness, thus, the primary rules of natural justice must be obeyed. The first rule is that a man must know the charge against him. The second rule is that he must have the chance to answer those charges. But how is a man to know the charge, unless the documents are served on him? Thus, service of documents is an important part of ensuring procedural justice.
Unfortunately, there are people who want to avoid service of documents, not for any social distancing reason but for simply to avoid being compelled to attend court. They think that by avoiding the court papers, they can later on challenge the court’s findings, because they were not part of the proceedings. They think that they can argue that the court orders have been unfairly given, because they did not give their side of the story. And so, they think that they can fight the case after it’s ended – it is ends in a way adverse to their interests.
Fortunately for plaintiffs everywhere, that is not quite the case. Documents which cannot be served to a defendant can still be served on a defendant, by substituted service. In the Malaysian courts, it means that a plaintiff who has tried, again and again, to serve court papers on a defendant, can go to the court and say, “My Lord, we have done this and this and this, and we failed to serve the court papers, can we please be allowed to serve it through a newspaper advertisement?”
And if the plaintiff has shown sufficient effort to serve the documents on the defendant, it is quite likely that the newspaper advertisement would be granted, on the expectation that the defendant would come to know about the court proceedings, and be compelled to come to court. And if the defendant fails to know about the court proceedings, at least, the newspaper suffices as a substitute for procedural fairness, to serve the interest of an ignorant or evasive defendant.
But the act of substituted service through a newspaper advertisement is a given, because that is how the industry has worked, and it is quite certain that the newspaper publication industry (in my country at least) is sustained in a large part through advertisements to call the defendants to come to court. They call it substituted service, but as a service, it can also be effectively delivered through Facebook advertising (for example), TV advertisement (for example), and even Internet advertising (for example). Imagine if the advertisement is placed at the bottom of the landing page of one of the leading websites of the day – it would certainly draw the attention of the defendant in no time.
Things look set to change. Over time, the courts have accepted service by way of email, and also instant messaging, and even social media. But web3 brings a new layer to that.
How Web3 changes Service of Court Documents
In the UK recently, a court allowed documents to be airdropped to the wallets of the defendants, as an NFT. The identities of the wallet owners were not known, and for many people in the space, wallets could be anonymous or pseudonymous. Thus, effecting service of documents through an NFT drop was an efficacious method. The UK case is D’Aloia v Binance Holdings & Others [2022], in which Mr D’Aloia was scammed into transferring tokens to unknown wallets, who ultimately transferred them to Binance-linked wallets. The court allowed Mr D’Aloia to serve the court papers to the parties through an airdrop to the said wallets.
This was not the first case of its type. Earlier in the year, service of court papers was also allowed by a court in New York, in the case of LCX AG vs John Does No. 1 to 25. LCX, an exchange in Lichtenstein, lost about USD8 million in Ethereum-based assets, due to theft, and identified the defendants as the culprit. However, the culprits were of unknown nationality. The case involved the use of Tornado Cash by the defendants, whose wallets were eventually identified through forensic methods. In that case, service of documents were also effected through an airdrop of an NFT.
Just yesterday, an interesting development has taken place as well. The CFTC has applied to the court for a declaration that it has served court papers on members of the Ooki DAO through its chat bots and forum posts. If this becomes a legal precedent, in the future, all members of a DAO could be deemed to have been served court papers, simply by sending messages to (a) the help chat bot, and (b) the online forum, both with a link to the press release about the court matter.
This space is developing and will continue to develop in interesting ways; but courts, which are used to enforce rights, will be tapped to give bite to the law. And in turn, the lawyers who serve the courts will be forced to think in ever more creative ways to serve documents, a necessary hurdle for them to obtain their court judgments. But having obtained those judgments eventually, will they also be able to enforce them in a meaningful way? Only time can tell.
Thanks for reading
This article has been prepared for general information only. Please get in touch with the BCTA team if you have any queries.

