VASPs and Ethical Issues in the Crypto Industry (part 1)


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software.


Note: Welcome to Part 1 of our 2 part article about VASPs and ethics. If you are interested in the topic, please check out Part 2, in which we address ethical failings in VASPs and what are some practical steps VASPs can implement. We even supply the text of a code of conduct to uphold ethics in VASPs.


Major events throughout 2022 have shown that the crypto industry is prone to fraud, misrepresentations, and other ethical failings. From Terraform Labs, the issuer of the LUNA token and its associated stablecoin, UST, to the crypto exchange FTX, and its FTT token, there are serious issues that plague the crypto industry. For that reason, regulations, which bind VASPs, or Virtual Asset Service Providers, have been put in place to compel compliance. Yet, despite the presence of compliance officers, and legal advisors, the unthinkable inevitably happened -- these projects imploded as a result of unethical behaviour. 


Therefore, in this article, we take a look at various ethical failings of these projects, and how VASPs should act to comply with the requirements of the law, and to act ethically.


What are ethics?

If you are working in the crypto industry, or if you are a participant, you may be wondering what ethics are, and what their relevance is to the industry. Simply put, ethics are a set of principles which may not have the same status of laws, but they are the guiding set of principles of right and wrong. The issues of ethical behaviour goes as far back to the time of Greek scholars, but, if you were to simplify, simply means, how should people act when they respect the rights of others ?


The Canadian government, in its website, writes the following: "Derived from the Greek word “ethos”, which means “way of living”, ethics is a branch of philosophy that is concerned with human conduct, more specifically the behaviour of individuals in society. Ethics examines the rational justification for our moral judgments; it studies what is morally right or wrong, just or unjust."


What is a VASP?

A VASP should not be confused with a wasp, which is a dangerous type of insect that humans should avoid. Instead, VASP stands for Virtual Asset Service Provider, a construct that was first promulgated by the FATF (Financial Action Task Force). 


The FATF defines "VASP" or “Virtual asset service provider” to mean, any natural or legal person not covered under the "FATF Recommendations" (more on that later), and, as a business conducts one or more of the following, for or on behalf of another natural or legal person:


i. Exchange between virtual assets and fiat currencies;

ii. Exchange between one or more forms of virtual assets;

iii. Transfer15 of virtual assets; and

iv. Safekeeping and/or administration of virtual assets or instruments enabling control over virtual assets;

v. Participation in and provision of financial services related to an issuer’s offer and/or sale of a virtual asset. 


(This article is still being researched and written, please come back soon)


What is a "virtual asset"?

FATF, in its guidelines, defines "Virtual Assets" to mean digital representation of value that can be digitally traded or transferred and can be used for payment or investment purposes.


For purposes of the definition, FATF excludes digital representations of fiat currencies, securities and other financial assets that are already covered elsewhere in the "FATF Recommendations".


Generally, NFTs are not considered "virtual assets", but could be included within the definition if the characteristics of a particular NFT, i.e. its nature and functions, are used for payment, or investment purposes. NFTs may also be considered as "financial assets" under existing FATF guidelines elsewhere, which would exclude them from the definition of "virtual asset".


What are the FATF Recommendations?

The "FATF Recommendations" mentioned in the VASP guidelines, refers to the FATF  Recommendations of "International Standards on Combating Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism and Proliferation", first adopted by the FATF Plenary in February 2012. 


After that, there were some additions through the FATF guidance for a risk-based approach on prepaid card, mobile payments, and Internet-based payment services, issued in June 2013. 


In June 2015, the FATF issued its guidelines for a risk-based approach to virtual currencies, which built on the 2013 document.


Finally in October 2021, the FATF issued its guidelines for a risk-based approach to virtual assets and virtual asset service providers. It is this last guideline which establishes the definitions of VASP and virtual assets.


Complying with FATF requirements

Under the FATF guidance, VASPs are required to implement a number of measures to prevent the abuse of virtual assets for illicit purposes. These measures include:


  1. Identifying and verifying the identity of customers: VASPs must implement procedures to identify and verify the identity of their customers, including the use of customer due diligence (CDD) measures.
  2. Monitoring transactions: VASPs must monitor transactions to detect and report suspicious activity. This includes implementing transaction monitoring systems and filing suspicious activity reports (SARs) as required.
  3. Maintaining records: VASPs must maintain records of their transactions, including the identities of their customers, for a specified period of time.
  4. Implementing internal policies and procedures: VASPs must have internal policies and procedures in place to comply with AML/CFT requirements, including the appointment of a compliance officer.


The FATF has also recommended that national governments require VASPs to register or obtain a license to operate, and that they be subject to supervision and oversight by competent authorities. This would allow authorities to ensure that VASPs are complying with AML/CFT requirements and to take action against those that are not.


Overall, the regulation of VASPs by the FATF is intended to reduce the risks of abuse of virtual assets for illicit purposes, and to ensure that VASPs are operating in a transparent and responsible manner.


Practical steps for VASPs to comply

 Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs) can take some practical steps to comply with Financial Action Task Force (FATF) guidelines:


  1. Implement customer due diligence (CDD) measures: VASPs should implement procedures to identify and verify the identity of their customers, including collecting and verifying information such as name, address, and date of birth.
  2. Monitor transactions: VASPs should implement systems to monitor transactions for suspicious activity, including setting up thresholds for transactions that trigger an alert and require further review.
  3. File suspicious activity reports (SARs): VASPs should have processes in place to file SARs as required by law or regulation. SARs should be filed when there is a reasonable suspicion that a transaction may be related to money laundering or terrorism financing.
  4. Maintain records: VASPs should maintain records of their transactions, including the identities of their customers, for a specified period of time.
  5. Implement internal policies and procedures: VASPs should have internal policies and procedures in place to comply with AML/CFT requirements, including the appointment of a compliance officer.
  6. Register or obtain a license: VASPs should register or obtain a license to operate, as required by national laws or regulations.
  7. Comply with supervisory and oversight requirements: VASPs should comply with any supervisory and oversight requirements imposed by competent authorities, including submitting reports and providing access to records as needed.


By taking these steps, VASPs can demonstrate their commitment to operating in a transparent and responsible manner, and reduce the risks of abuse of virtual assets for illicit purposes.


Guidelines from other governmental authorities regarding VASPs

There are a number of other governmental guidelines that are similar to the Financial Action Task Force's (FATF) guidelines for regulating Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs). Here are a few examples:


  1. The U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) has issued guidance on the regulation of VASPs, including requirements for customer identification and transaction monitoring.
  2. The European Union (EU) has adopted the Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive (5AMLD), which includes provisions for the regulation of VASPs. The 5AMLD requires VASPs to register with competent authorities, implement CDD measures, and report suspicious transactions.
  3. The United Kingdom (UK) has adopted the Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (Amendment) Regulations 2019, which includes provisions for the regulation of VASPs. The regulations require VASPs to register with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), implement CDD measures, and report suspicious transactions.
  4. The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) has issued guidelines on the regulation of VASPs, including requirements for customer identification, transaction monitoring, and reporting suspicious transactions.


In addition to the regulatory frameworks outlined above, there are also a number of other initiatives and guidelines that aim to promote the responsible use of virtual assets and reduce the risks of abuse for illicit purposes.


One example is the Global Digital Finance (GDF) Code of Conduct, which is a set of voluntary principles for the responsible use of digital assets in the financial industry. The Code of Conduct covers a range of topics, including customer protection, governance, and risk management, and is intended to provide a framework for firms operating in the digital asset space to demonstrate their commitment to operating in a responsible and transparent manner.


Another example is the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision's (BCBS) "Guidance for a risk-based approach to virtual assets and virtual asset service providers," which provides guidance to banks on how to manage the risks associated with virtual assets and VASPs. The guidance covers topics such as customer due diligence, transaction monitoring, and risk management, and is intended to help banks identify and manage the risks associated with virtual assets and VASPs.


The Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) in the United States has also issued guidance on the risks associated with virtual assets and VASPs, and has recommended that financial institutions adopt a risk-based approach when dealing with these types of firms. The FSOC guidance covers topics such as customer due diligence, transaction monitoring, and risk management, and is intended to help financial institutions identify and manage the risks associated with virtual assets and VASPs.


Guidelines for VASPs from the BIS

The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) is an international organization that serves as a bank for central banks. The BIS does not have the authority to issue regulatory guidelines for Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs). However, the BIS does provide guidance on the potential risks and challenges associated with virtual assets, and has encouraged central banks and other regulatory authorities to consider these risks when developing their own regulatory frameworks for VASPs.


In 2019, the BIS released a report on "Central bank digital currencies," which discussed the potential risks and challenges associated with virtual assets, including the potential for money laundering and terrorism financing. The report recommended that central banks and other regulatory authorities consider the risks associated with virtual assets when developing their regulatory frameworks, and suggested a number of areas where further work and analysis might be needed, including the regulation of VASPs.


In 2021, the BIS released a report on "Stablecoins and central bank digital currencies," which discussed the potential risks and challenges associated with stablecoins, which are a type of virtual asset that is pegged to a real-world asset or currency. The report recommended that central banks and other regulatory authorities consider the risks associated with stablecoins when developing their regulatory frameworks, and suggested a number of areas where further work and analysis might be needed, including the regulation of VASPs.


Overall, while the BIS does not have the authority to issue regulatory guidelines for VASPs, it has provided guidance on the potential risks and challenges associated with virtual assets, and has encouraged regulatory authorities to consider these risks when developing their own regulatory frameworks.


Thanks for reading - watch out for part 2

Due to the length of this article, we have to break it down into two articles! In this article, we briefly touched on the definition of VASPs under the FATF guidelines; and we covered what was needed to comply with those guidelines. In addition, we touched on similar guidelines from other governmental authorities. 


However, the issue of ethics is an important one. We will try to cover that in part 2 of this article. Thanks for reading!


Note: Please do not consider this article as legal advice. This article was prepared for general information only.