VASPs and Ethical Issues in the Crypto Industry (part 2)


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software

Ethical Failings of VASPs

Welcome to Part 2 of our two part article! If you haven't already, please check out part 1 of this article in which we discuss the definition of VASPs as defined by the FATF guidelines..


Even though VASPs are a relatively new industry, there have been a number of notable ethical failings involving VASPs (virtual asset service providers). Here are a few prominent examples over the years (pre-2022):


Mt. Gox: In 2014, the Mt. Gox VASP, which at the time was one of the largest exchanges for the virtual asset Bitcoin, filed for bankruptcy after it was revealed that 850,000 Bitcoins, worth around $450 million at the time, had been stolen from the exchange. The hack was later attributed to a failure to properly secure the exchange's systems and a lack of transparency about the security measures that were in place.


Cryptopia: In 2019, the Cryptopia VASP suffered a significant security breach, resulting in the theft of an estimated $16 million worth of virtual assets. The breach was later attributed to a failure to properly secure the exchange's systems and a lack of transparency about the security measures that were in place.


QuadrigaCX: In 2019, the QuadrigaCX VASP filed for bankruptcy after it was revealed that the company's founder, who was the only person with access to the company's cold storage wallets, had died, and the wallets were subsequently lost. The incident raised questions about the company's financial management and transparency, and led to a legal battle over the recovery of customer funds.


Bitfinex: In 2016, the Bitfinex VASP suffered a significant security breach, resulting in the theft of 120,000 Bitcoins, worth around $72 million at the time. The breach was later attributed to a failure to properly secure the exchange's systems and a lack of transparency about the security measures that were in place.


Binance: In 2019, the Binance VASP suffered a significant security breach, resulting in the theft of 7,000 Bitcoins, worth around $41 million at the time. The breach was later attributed to a failure to properly secure the exchange's systems and a lack of transparency about the security measures that were in place.


Coincheck: In 2018, the Coincheck VASP suffered a significant security breach, resulting in the theft of 500 million NEM coins, worth around $530 million at the time. The breach was later attributed to a failure to properly secure the exchange's systems and a lack of transparency about the security measures that were in place.


BitMEX: In 2020, the BitMEX VASP was criticized for its lack of transparency and failure to properly disclose the conflicts of interest of its founders, who held significant positions at the company while also investing in virtual assets. The incident raised concerns about the company's governance and integrity.


OneCoin: In 2019, the OneCoin VASP was revealed to be a Ponzi scheme, with the company's founders charged with fraud and money laundering. The incident raised concerns about the risks associated with virtual assets and the importance of due diligence when investing in them.


Ethical Failings of VASPs in 2022

In 2022, the world witnessed ethics failings from several large VASPs. The biggest to date, by far, was FTX. 


FTX has been criticized for a number of ethical failings, by its new CEO, who took over following its filing for bankruptcy, who cited the misuse of customer funds, lack of accurate financial information, poor record keeping, and the use of software to conceal the misuse of customer funds. FTX's CEO Sam Bankman-Fried was also accused of communicating using apps that automatically deleted messages and encouraging staff to do the same. FTX's collapse also raises concerns about "ethics washing", where companies present themselves as ethical but fail to live up to their promises. FTX's collapse demonstrates the need for ethics and compliance in business.


Terraform Labs have been criticized for selling its token at 18 cents per token during its seed round, and 80 cents during a private sale; and later on, it was accused of luring investors with attractive, high staking yields for its $UST token, which ultimately proved unsustainable, leading to the collapse of the token, and the company. Terraform's founder, Do Kwon, repeatedly denied any suggestions that the token was vulnerable to attack, making fun of critics on social media. The crash wiped out $40 billion in market value. In September 2022, South Korean prosecutors issued a warrant for the arrest of the founder, Do Kwon.


US authorities are investigating whether Sam Bankman-Fried of FTX manipulated the prices of TerraUSD and Terra LUNA to benefit firms he controlled, such as FTX and Alameda Research. Among the allegations, is that he placed short positions to benefit from falling LUNA prices during the May crash, and that a big chunk of UST sell orders may have come from Alameda Research. If true, the manipulation may have caused a domino effect in the crypto markets.


Three Arrows Capital, a Singapore trading firm, was one of the major casualties in the fallout of the Terra Luna collapse. Three Arrows Capital has been censured by the Singapore Central Bank for alleged misleading and false disclosures. The crypto hedge fund also exceeded the leverage limits set by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Poor risk management, recklessness in dealing with leverage, and credit being withdrawn due to tightened underwriting standards have all been cited as potential causes of Three Arrows Capital's bankruptcy.  The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) reprimanded 3AC for filing false information. By using leverage, 3AC was able to secure $10 billion, which was all ultimately lost in its collapse. 3AC's collapse caused Voyager's subsequent bankruptcy. 3AC built its position using high leverage via counterparty funds, without the knowledge of the counterparties. The downfall of 3AC has been attributed to a mix of poor risk management, recklessness in dealing with counterparty funds, and an inability to meet margin calls. 


Beyond Blame: Dive into root causes

Frustrated crypto investors have unearthed an academic article from 2013 by Barbara H Fried, "Beyond Blame". It is noteworthy that Barbara H Fried is the mother of Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of FTX.com, and she is also a law professor emerita.


In the article, Fried discusses the concept of blame and its role in society and in organizations.


Fried argues that blame is often used as a way to avoid taking responsibility for problems or mistakes, and that this can be counter-productive and lead to a culture of avoidance and defensiveness within organizations. She suggests that instead of assigning blame, organizations should focus on understanding and addressing the root causes of problems, and on creating a culture of accountability and continuous improvement.


Fried also discusses the importance of leadership in creating a culture that is focused on learning and improvement, rather than blame. She suggests that leaders can foster a culture of accountability and continuous improvement by setting clear expectations, providing support and resources to help employees learn and grow, and by creating a safe and open environment for employees to raise concerns and seek feedback.


Overall, Fried's article argues that organizations should move beyond a focus on blame and instead focus on understanding and addressing the root causes of problems, and on creating a culture of accountability and continuous improvement.


So, in line with Fried's suggestions, perhaps it is appropriate to look at what companies can do to address ethical failings, and how to improve the ethical decision making in their internal organizations.

 

Common Ethical Failings in VASPs

Ethical failings can and do occur in Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs). These include:


Money laundering: VASPs may facilitate laundering of proceeds of crime or other illicit activities, allowing customers to transfer funds anonymously or failing to implement sufficient safeguards to detect and report suspicious activity.


Terrorism financing: VASPs may facilitate financing of terrorism, allowing customers to transfer funds anonymously or failing to implement sufficient safeguards to detect and report suspicious activity.


Unfair or deceptive practices: VASPs may engage in unfair or deceptive practices, by charging exorbitant fees, providing false or misleading information to customers, or failing to disclose risks associated with virtual assets.


Insufficient security measures: VASPs may have insufficient security measures in place to protect customer funds or data, thus exposing customers to the risk of fraud or theft.


Lack of transparency: Some VASPs lack transparency in their operations or decision-making processes, which lead to concerns about the company's integrity and accountability.


Lack of customer protection: VASPs may not have sufficient measures in place to protect their customers interests, e.g. by failing to adequately disclose risks associated with virtual assets or by providing inadequate customer support.


Misuse of customer data: VASPs may misuse customer data, by selling it to third parties without customer consent or by using it for purposes other than those for which it was collected.


Lack of responsible business practices: VASPs may fail to follow responsible business practices, by failing to respect the environment or by engaging in activities that may have negative social or economic impacts.


Discrimination or harassment: VASPs may have a culture of discrimination or harassment, which create a negative working environment and undermine the trust of employees and other stakeholders.


These ethical failings undermine the trust of customers and other stakeholders in VASPs, and pose risks to the integrity and stability of the virtual asset industry. VASPs must operate in a transparent and responsible manner, and implement measures to prevent and address these types of ethical failings.


Commingling of Funds: A Major Ethical Failing

Commingling of funds refers to the practice of mixing customer funds with the operating funds of a company. In the context of a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP), commingling of funds could be considered an ethical failing if it is not properly disclosed to customers and if it poses a risk to the safety and security of customer funds. In small businesses, like mom and pop stores, commingling of funds might not be a risk; but when a company handles customers' funds, commingling of funds poses a danger to the customers because their funds can go missing over time!


If a VASP commingles customer funds with its own operating funds, it can create confusion and make it difficult for customers to track the movement of their funds. This can pose a risk to the safety and security of customer funds, as it can be more difficult for customers to know whether their funds are being used for their intended purposes or for the benefit of the VASP.


Additionally, if a VASP commingles customer funds with its own operating funds without properly disclosing this practice to customers, it can be considered deceptive or unfair. Customers have a right to know how their funds are being used, and if a VASP does not disclose its practice of commingling funds, it may be considered unethical.


Commingling of funds is generally not a punishable offense in and of itself, but it can be a symptom of other unlawful or unethical activities. When funds are commingled, they can be embezzled, abused, or otherwise drained, causing losses to investors and depositors, in a way that is not transparent or properly accounted for. This can be a problem because it can make it difficult to track the flow of money and determine how it is being used.


In some cases, commingling of funds may be illegal if it is done for the purpose of hiding or disguising the true nature of financial transactions, such as in cases of money laundering or embezzlement. In other cases, commingling of funds may be unethical if it is done to deceive or mislead others, or if it is done in a way that violates the terms of a contract or trust. 


In the case of FTX, its terms of service clearly stated that it would not touch its customers' funds, i.e. it would not commingle its customers' funds. FTX's former CEO, Sam Bankman-Fried, has denied knowingly commingling customers' funds. However, reports suggest that between $1 billion to $2 billion of customer funds have vanished from the exchange, thanks to a secret "back door" that allowed Sam Bankman-Fried to access funds without the dealings reflected on the accounting records. Bankman-Fried's trading firm Alameda Research reportedly owes FTX $10 billion after taking loans from customer deposits. In an interview with the New York Times, Sam Bankman-Fried said, "I didn’t ever try to commit fraud."


Where a VASP is a fiduciary, or holds a fiduciary duty to its clients, who rely upon it to keep their funds safe, the commingling of funds can be a punishable offence. Thus a fiduciary who blends their own funds with those of their customers, commits an offence which can lead to punishment. This could lead to the piercing of the corporate veil, whereby the court orders the persons behind a corporate entity to be personally responsible for the actions of the corporate entity, which they control.


To avoid commingling, it is important to maintain separate accounts and file specific paperwork to properly separate personal belongings from company assets


Image created by Kevin Koo using AI software


Practical Steps to Address Ethical Failings

Here are a few steps that companies can take to address ethical issues in their organizations:


Establish an ethical code of conduct: Companies can establish an ethical code of conduct that sets out the values and principles that the organization is committed to upholding. This code of conduct should be communicated to all employees, and should be widely available to stakeholders such as customers, suppliers, and shareholders.


Implement training programs: Companies can implement training programs to educate employees about ethical issues and how to handle them. These programs can cover topics such as conflict of interest, discrimination and harassment, and ethical decision-making.


Establish a system for reporting and addressing ethical issues: Companies should establish a system for employees to report ethical concerns or breaches of the ethical code of conduct. This system should provide a confidential and anonymous way for employees to raise concerns, and should have processes in place to investigate and address any issues that are raised. (This is also known as a "whistleblower program".)


Promote transparency: Companies should be transparent about their operations and decision-making processes, and should make information about their business practices and policies widely available to stakeholders.


Ensure accountability: Companies should hold themselves and their employees accountable for ethical behavior, and should have processes in place to ensure that ethical breaches are addressed and rectified.


Engage with stakeholders: Companies should engage with their stakeholders, such as employees, customers, suppliers, and shareholders, to understand their concerns and expectations regarding ethical behavior. This can help companies identify and address ethical issues, and build trust with their stakeholders.


Incorporate ethical considerations into business decisions: Companies should make ethical considerations an integral part of their decision-making processes, and should ensure that ethical considerations are taken into account when making business decisions.


Review and update policies and procedures: Companies should regularly review and update their policies and procedures to ensure that they are consistent with ethical standards and evolving legal and regulatory requirements.


Establish a corporate social responsibility program: Companies can establish a corporate social responsibility (CSR) program to demonstrate their commitment to ethical and sustainable business practices. CSR programs can include initiatives such as charitable giving, environmental protection, and diversity and inclusion.


Benefits of Implementing a Whistleblower Program

Whistleblower programs can be an effective tool for addressing ethical issues in companies. A whistleblower program is a system that allows employees or other stakeholders to report ethical concerns or breaches of the ethical code of conduct within an organization. Whistleblower programs can provide a confidential and anonymous way for employees to raise concerns, and can help companies identify and address ethical issues that might otherwise go undetected.


There are a number of benefits to establishing a whistleblower program. For example:


Identifying and addressing ethical issues: A whistleblower program can help companies identify and address ethical issues that might otherwise go undetected. By providing a confidential and anonymous way for employees to report concerns, a whistleblower program can encourage employees to speak up about ethical issues and help ensure that these issues are addressed.


Promoting transparency and accountability: A whistleblower program can promote transparency and accountability within an organization, by providing a way for employees to report ethical concerns and ensuring that these concerns are addressed.


Building trust with stakeholders: A whistleblower program can help build trust with stakeholders, by demonstrating the company's commitment to ethical behavior and its willingness to take action to address ethical issues.


Reducing legal and reputational risks: By addressing ethical issues, a whistleblower program can help reduce legal and reputational risks for a company.


Overall, a whistleblower program can be an effective tool for addressing ethical issues in a company, and can help promote transparency, accountability, and trust within the organization.


Implementing a Whistleblower Program Effectively

There are a number of measures that companies can take to protect whistleblowers when they report against the CEO or other high-level executives:


Implement a strong whistleblower policy: Companies should have a strong and clearly-communicated whistleblower policy that outlines the procedures for reporting unethical behavior, including when it involves the CEO or other high-level executives. The policy should also provide protection from retaliation for those who report such behavior in good faith.


Establish an independent reporting mechanism: Companies should establish an independent reporting mechanism, such as a hotline or an anonymous reporting system, that allows whistleblowers to report unethical behavior without fear of retaliation.


Ensure confidentiality: Companies should take steps to protect the confidentiality of whistleblowers, and should not disclose the identity of the whistleblower unless it is necessary to do so in order to investigate the report.


Protect against retaliation: Companies should have strong policies in place to protect against retaliation against whistleblowers, and should take prompt and appropriate action to address any instances of retaliation.


Encourage a culture of ethical behavior: Companies should encourage a culture of ethical behavior and should encourage employees to report any concerns or issues that they have. This can be done through training programs, communication efforts, and by setting a positive example through the leadership of the company.


Companies must have strong measures in place to protect whistleblowers and to encourage a culture of ethical behavior. By doing so, companies can create a safe and open environment for employees to raise concerns and seek guidance, which can help to prevent and address unethical behavior within the organization.


Sample Code of Conduct for VASPs - Free to Use

Here is a sample text for an ethical code of conduct for a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP):


1. Introduction:

Our company is committed to operating in an ethical and responsible manner, and to upholding the highest standards of integrity and professionalism. This code of conduct sets out the values and principles that guide our behavior as a company and as individuals.


2. Compliance with laws and regulations:

We are committed to complying with all applicable laws and regulations, including those related to virtual assets and anti-money laundering. We will take all necessary steps to ensure that our operations are in compliance with these laws and regulations.


3. Honesty and transparency:

We are committed to honesty and transparency in all of our business dealings, and to providing accurate and complete information to our customers and other stakeholders. We will be open and transparent about our policies and procedures, and about the risks and potential benefits of our services.


4. Protecting customer funds:

We are committed to protecting the safety and security of our customers' funds. We will implement appropriate security measures to prevent fraud or theft, and will promptly notify customers of any incidents that may affect the safety or security of their funds.


5. Protecting customer privacy:

We are committed to protecting the privacy of our customers and will only use customer data in accordance with applicable laws and regulations and with the customer's consent. We will maintain appropriate security measures to protect customer data from unauthorized access or disclosure.


6. Fair treatment of customers:

We are committed to fair treatment of our customers and will not discriminate against or harass any customer on the basis of age, race, religion, gender, sexual orientation, or any other protected characteristic. We will also strive to provide excellent customer service and to resolve any issues or complaints in a timely and fair manner.


7. Ethical business practices:

We are committed to ethical business practices and will not engage in deceptive or fraudulent activities. We will also strive to minimize any negative impact of our operations on the environment and on society.


8. Reporting unethical behavior:

We encourage our employees and other stakeholders to report any unethical behavior or potential violations of this code of conduct. We will protect the confidentiality of those who report such behavior and will take appropriate action to address any violations.


9. Conflicts of interest:

We are committed to disclosing and managing any conflicts of interest that may arise in the course of our business. We will take appropriate steps to ensure that any conflicts of interest do not compromise our obligations to our customers or to the integrity of our operations.


10. Whistleblower protection:

We will protect the confidentiality and rights of employees or other stakeholders who report unethical behavior or potential violations of this code of conduct. We will not tolerate retaliation against those who report such behavior in good faith.


11. Training and education:

We will provide training and education to our employees and other stakeholders about this code of conduct and about ethical issues that may arise in the course of our business. We will also encourage our employees and other stakeholders to seek guidance and support if they have any questions or concerns about ethical issues.


12. Review and update:

We will review and update this code of conduct on a regular basis to ensure that it reflects our commitment to ethical behavior and to comply with evolving legal and regulatory requirements.


Overall, this code of conduct sets out the values and principles that guide our behavior as a company and as individuals, and reflects our commitment to upholding ethical behavior in our company.


Thank you very much for reading

We thank you for reading this article! We hope that it has been helpful.


Please note that this article should not be considered a substitute for legal advice. Please consult with a lawyer before making any decision.


Please feel free to reach out to the author on Twitter if you have any comments.